Tuesday, April 7, 2026

Book review: THEN THERE WAS YOU, by S.L. Scott


This book felt like watching two lonely souls finally find the one person who sees them. Keats Mathews grew up with nothing—an alcoholic mother who chose the bar over him, a childhood built on ramen and white bread, and a life where he had to raise himself. And yet, he’s this quiet, hardworking, beautiful soul who studies finance on a scholarship, writes in secret, and works every job he can find just to stay afloat.

The moment that truly got me was the way he answers the second line of a poem she quotes, like it came straight from his heart. Thud. I melted.


Sosie Stansbury is his opposite on paper—billionaire daughter, fancy life, all the resources in the world. But she’s neglected, paraded around for show, and basically raised by staff while her parents chase their social calendar. Even her birthday isn’t hers. She’s rich in money and poor in love.


Their first meeting on Christmas Eve felt magical. She steals a cigarette from him and accidentally steals his heart too. They spend one night together that is absolutely not a hookup—it’s two people recognizing each other’s loneliness and offering warmth. He can’t promise her much, but he offers himself completely, and she accepts.


And then her father destroys everything. The threats, the manipulation, the way she sacrifices her own happiness to protect Keats—it broke me. When Keats shows up to return her phone and gets threatened too, both of them walk away shattered.


Years pass. Keats becomes the golden boy of his firm. Sosie becomes the perfect daughter in a fake relationship. They meet again, twice, and both times it feels like fate is trying so hard to push them together, but life keeps getting in the way. Star‑crossed lovers indeed.


When Greg traps her with a public proposal and she runs—runs—straight to Keats, I cheered. From that moment, they choose each other, even when everything else falls apart. She gets cut off, loses her cards, her job, her safety net. He gets mugged and she finds him unconscious in a hospital, staying by his side until he’s discharged. They rebuild their lives together, piece by piece.


Sosie gets a job, picks up photography again, starts healing. Keats reconnects with his mother, who is finally sober and trying. Their worlds slowly knit into something warm and real.


The wedding scene—simple, intimate, with only the people who truly love them—was perfect. And the ending, with Sosie showing him the positive pregnancy test, felt like the softest, sweetest full‑circle moment.


This story is about love, yes, but also about choosing yourself, choosing healing, choosing the person who sees you when no one else ever did. It’s tender, hopeful, and full of heart. I loved every page.


Purchase links


https://geni.us/TTWYAm


Available in KU 



About the author


New York Times and USA Today Bestselling Author, S.L. Scott, writes character driven, heart-racing suspense, and swoony romances that will leave you glued to the page. With stories ranging from witty beach reads to heart wrenching and heart healing, her stories are highly regarded as emotional, relatable, and captivating.


Her books are more than escapes for the voracious readers of today. They are journeys of the heart that always come with a happily ever after reward at the end.


For more information, visit her website and sign up for her newsletter. She also loves to connect with readers on social media.


Connect with S.L. Scott:

https://linktr.ee/s.l.scott


No comments:

Post a Comment

Book review: THEN THERE WAS YOU, by S.L. Scott

This book felt like watching two lonely souls finally find the one person who sees them. Keats Mathews grew up with nothing—an alcoholic mot...